Half-empty shelves, unfulfilled orders, and disappointed customers. These are the hallmarks of a business struggling with a low fill rate.
Fill rate is a critical metric that directly impacts your bottom line and customer satisfaction. Yet, many distributors underestimate how much a subpar fill rate is costing them until the damage is already done.
In this article, we’ll dive into the world of fill rates and uncover:
By the end of this article, you’ll have a clear understanding of how fill rate impacts your business and actionable steps to improve it.
Fill rate is a key metric in supply chain management that measures the percentage of customer orders fulfilled from available stock. It’s calculated by dividing the number of an item’s sales order lines shipped by the total number of lines ordered (businesses might choose to use units, COGS or other metrics instead of lines, but the idea is the same). For example, if a distributor receives 5 orders for an item and has the stock to completely fulfill 4 of those orders, they have an 80%
fill rate.
This metric provides valuable insights into the efficiency of a company’s inventory management and order fulfillment processes. A high fill rate indicates that a large portion of customer demands are being met, maximizing customer satisfaction and revenue potential. Conversely, a low fill rate suggests missed opportunities and potential customer dissatisfaction. Low fill rates also come with lots of related costs, including split shipments, canceled orders, and customer service overhead.
By monitoring and optimizing fill rate, businesses can identify areas for improvement in their supply chain and maximize their operational efficiency.
There are various types of fill rates, each measuring different aspects of order fulfillment.
These metrics provide insights into the efficiency and effectiveness of different stages in the supply chain process.
This metric measures the percentage of customer orders where all units on all lines are fulfilled completely on the first shipment. It’s calculated by dividing the number of complete orders shipped by the total number of orders received. Order fill rate provides a high-level picture of overall order fulfillment efficiency. This is also called the “perfect order” rate.
Line fill rate is the percentage of sales order lines filled completely in the first shipment. This metric helps identify specific products or categories that may be causing fulfillment issues. A low line fill rate might signal inventory shortages or picking errors for certain items. By tracking line fill rate, businesses can pinpoint problem areas in their inventory or fulfillment processes.
Unit fill rate assesses the number of cases shipped compared to the number of cases ordered. It’s particularly relevant for businesses dealing with bulk orders or case-packed items. This metric helps evaluate the accuracy of case-level inventory management and order fulfillment processes.
COGS fill rate assesses the number of sales order dollars (at cost) shipped compared to COGS ordered.
For businesses with multiple warehouses, it’s critical to ensure that you track both the network fill rate (i.e. the percentage of demand available at the time of order, including stock at all facilities) as well as each facility fill rate (i.e. the percentage of local demand that is available at the time of order at your nearest shipping origin). Many businesses only track their network fill rate, causing them to significantly under-count the financial and customer service impact of failing to ship material from the closest location to your customer.
Grouping items by their preferred vendor allows you to measure your own fill rate at the vendor level. This can businesses to assess vendor reliability and spot performance trends that are the result of vendor performance. While vendors are only partially responsible for your outbound fill rates, tracking this can help you make informed decisions about supplier relationships and inventory sourcing strategies. A consistently low vendor fill rate might signal the need to diversify suppliers or work closely with existing ones to improve performance.
Calculating fill rate involves a straightforward formula that measures the percentage of demand fulfilled from available inventory.
The fill rate formula is:
Fill Rate = (Total Units Shipped / Total Units Ordered) x 100
This formula calculates the percentage of units successfully shipped compared to the total units ordered. A higher fill rate indicates better inventory management and customer satisfaction.
Consider an automotive parts distributor receiving an order for 500 brake pads:
Fill Rate = (475 / 500) x 100 = 95%
In this example, the distributor’s fill rate is 95%, which suggests effective inventory management and order fulfillment processes. However, there’s still room for improvement to achieve a 100% fill rate and maximize customer satisfaction.
A common question distributors ask is “What should my fill rate be?” The truth is, there’s no universal answer. Some businesses have profit-maximizing fill rates in the 80% range, while others exceed 99%. Several factors influence the ideal fill rate for a business.
The key is to avoid setting a single target fill rate for every item. Instead, distributors should consider certain factors when determining appropriate fill rate targets for each product they sell.
Profitability is a key factor. Prioritizing higher fill rates for items with higher gross margins ensures that companies maintain consistent revenue streams from their most valuable products.
Holding costs are also important. Items that are less expensive to store, such as small, compact goods, can justify higher fill rates as they take up less warehouse space.
Sales volume and variance should be considered as well. Aiming for higher fill rates on
high-volume items is essential, but it’s equally important to consider sales variance. Items with consistent, predictable demand are easier to manage and can achieve higher fill rates efficiently.
Lead time is another factor that affects fill rate targets. Items with longer or more variable lead times naturally require higher safety stock levels to compensate for potential delays. This can justify slightly lower fill rate targets for these items.
Finally, some items, regardless of their profitability or volume, are strategically important to a business. These products might be essential components of larger orders or represent the company’s own brand. Ensuring high fill rates for these strategic products is crucial for maintaining customer satisfaction and brand reputation.
Fill rate is a key performance indicator that impacts various aspects of your business.
This is a metric that directly affects customer satisfaction by ensuring timely order fulfillment. Companies with consistently high fill rates often see:
There are plenty of good reasons to keep track of fill rates, especially because it can facilitate smoother operations. Monitoring fill rates helps businesses:
Furthermore, a high fill rate can significantly impact your bottom line. It can lead to:
From unexpected demand spikes to supplier delays, a myriad of factors can wreak havoc on your fill rate, leading to frustrated customers and lost revenue. Improving your fill rate requires a multifaceted approach that addresses various aspects of your business operations. Here are key strategies to enhance your fill rate performance:
Businesses implement just-in-time (JIT) inventory systems to reduce excess stock while ensuring product availability. Advanced inventory tracking software helps monitor stock levels in real-time, triggering automatic reorders when supplies run low.
Implementing ABC analysis categorizes products based on demand, allowing for tailored inventory strategies for each category. Regular cycle counts and periodic audits ensure accuracy in inventory records, preventing stockouts and overstocking.
Establishing clear communication channels with suppliers facilitates better coordination and faster issue resolution. Implementing vendor-managed inventory (VMI) programs allows suppliers to monitor and replenish stock levels directly.
Performance-based contracts incentivize suppliers to maintain high service levels. Collaborative forecasting involves sharing demand predictions with suppliers, enabling them to adjust production schedules accordingly. Regular supplier performance reviews help identify areas for improvement and foster long-term partnerships.
Implementing warehouse management systems (WMS) optimizes picking, packing, and shipping operations. Cross-docking techniques reduce handling time and storage requirements for fast-moving items. Automated sorting systems and conveyor belts speed up order processing.
Batch picking methods increase efficiency for multi-line orders. Implementing pick-to-light or voice-picking technologies reduces errors and improves accuracy. Regular analysis of fulfillment metrics helps identify bottlenecks and opportunities for process improvements, ensuring timely and accurate order completion.
Fill rate is a crucial metric, but it’s not the only one to consider when assessing inventory performance from a customer service perspective. Another important metric is the in-stock rate. Both measure different aspects of your ability to meet customer demand, and understanding their nuances can help you make more informed decisions about inventory management.
The primary difference between an in-stock rate and a fill rate is that in-stock rates measure expected demand, while fill rates focus on actual customer orders. In-stock rates are typically based on sales forecasts, meaning that if an item hasn’t sold recently and has a zero forecast, having zero units on hand won’t affect your in-stock rate.
However, this doesn’t mean a customer won’t buy it. This highlights a key advantage of fill rate as a customer service metric. Your customer doesn’t care about your forecast. If they want an item, they expect you to have it, regardless of your predictions. Consequently, a fill rate accurately reflects customer satisfaction, as it considers every instance where you couldn’t fulfill an order.
On the other hand, in-stock rate has its own advantages. It acknowledges that even if no one buys a product, being out of stock still represents an inventory failure with direct consequences for your top line. For example, if you have a sales forecast of 30 units but are out of stock, your in-stock rate will reflect this failure, even though your fill rate won’t be affected because no sales
were attempted.
This difference becomes even more critical when dealing with products or businesses where customers are highly sensitive to stock status. If a customer won’t even place an order if an item is out of stock, both your backorder rate and fill rate will remain unaffected, providing a false sense of security. In such situations, the in-stock rate provides a more accurate picture of potential
lost sales.
Given these advantages and disadvantages, tracking both fill rate and in-stock rate is essential for a comprehensive understanding of your inventory performance. They offer different perspectives on customer service and inventory efficiency, enabling you to address potential shortcomings in your supply chain.
Fill rate is a critical indicator of your business’s health and efficiency.
Fill rate is about meeting customer expectations, optimizing inventory management, and streamlining your entire supply chain.
But word to the wise: improving your fill rate isn’t a one-time fix. It requires a multifaceted approach, involving strategies like optimizing inventory levels, enhancing supplier relationships, and streamlining order fulfillment processes.
So, take a close look at your fill rate. Analyze it, understand its impact, and implement strategies to improve it. Your customers — and your bottom line — will thank you.
Contact us to learn more.
Introduction In the aerospace MRO sector, operational efficiency is paramount. Downtime is costly, and delays in maintenance or...
Get updates on the latest news across all core inventory-related processes.
Subscribe now!
Your email is safe with us, we dont spam.
